Lot 11    

Military Vest and CDV of Capt. Henry B. Hays, 6th US Cavalry
4/30/2014 - Firearms and Militaria: Live Salesroom Auction
Hay's outstanding blue wool military vest in pristine condition along with a wartime CDV of the captain possibly wearing the nine button frock coat being sold as Lot 9. Vest of typical cut with nine razor sharp cuff sized gilded eagle "C" marked "Paris T.W. & W."  Vest with two outside pockets on the left and one on the right lined in a brown polish cotton.  Interior lined in white polished cotton, the back in dark polish cotton all in perfect condition except for some minor staining underneath the arm pits.

The vignette CDV by Porter's Gallery, Cincinnati depicts Hays wearing his military frock coat unbuttoned at top revealing a silk cravat and vest underneath. The flamboyant captains sports a mustache of epic length said to have been the most "luxuriant mustache in the army." 

Heavy navy blue wool cavalry officer's nine-button single-breasted frock coat with "Smith's Patent" captain shoulder straps and custom captain cuff braids in black silk.  Gilt buttons are marked "Schuyler Hartley & Graham N.Y."  Skirt measures 19.5" to rough edge.  Bell-shaped elbows measuring 9.5".  Back of coat has custom braiding right below the color and above the center vent. Vent has two buttons at top and middle of the vent.  Coat has three-button non-serviceable cuffs. The lining is a very dark olive, almost charcoal in color with a close quilt pattern throughout the chest and shoulders. Sleeves are lined in white and collar is lined in black velvet. On the left inside of jacket there is a leather belt with brass clip (right side missing).  Marked on the inside of right sleeve in ink : "Captain H. B. Hayes 6th Cavalry U.S. Army."

Henry Blake Hays (1829-1881) was a Pennsylvania-born diplomat, soldier, and wealthy coal baron whose extensive business interests encompassed banking, mining and railroads. Hays is best remembered for opening up the coal fields of Allegheny region and by extension building the system of narrow gauge railroads that efficiently transported the coal from the mines to the market.

Trained as a Civil Engineer, Henry Hays started his career as a diplomat. In 1850 he was was appointed attaché to the American Legation in Copenhagen later serving a private secretary to the US Minister to Denmark. Thanks to his linguistic ability, Hays traveled far afield during his early diplomatic career visiting the cities of the Byzantine Holy Land, exotic Egypt, and the Russia Empire in the wake of the Crimean War. In 1857 he returned home to employ his civil engineering credentials and immediately set to work building narrow gauge railroads as the coal industry sat posed on the cusp of expansion.

With the advent of the Civil War Henry Hays used his connections to obtain a regular commission as Captain in the 3rd US Cavalry in May 1861 which was rejected on the grounds of seniority by the Senate. On August 5, 1861 Hay’s was reappointed Captain in the newly organized 6th US Cavalry then being raised at Pittsburgh, but prevaricated and took over a month to accept. During Hays’ tenure the regiment served exclusively in the Army of the Potomac participating in over one hundred fifteen engagements including every notable fight and raid undertaken by the ardent troopers of Cavalry Corps. The Northern press soon became enamored by the exploits of the Cavalry Corps where glory abounded amidst reputations that ebbed and flowed among its flamboyant crop of leaders.

Hays must have speculatively been perceived as something of an outsider—an untried regular—as he remained in Pittsburgh on recruiting duty until January 1862 and periodically thereafter as mustering and disbursing officer posted to less glowing administrative duties according to his Military Record (1873). However, Hays’ Dictionary of American Biography reads differently—as if it were embellished— asserting that he was present with the 6th Cavalry from “Williamsburg, Mechanicsville, Hanover Court House, where he was recommended for promotion, Malvern Hill, South Mountain, Culpepper Court House, Upperville, Chancellorsville , Brandy Station and Beverly Ford. Unfortunately, Hay’s National Archive military records seem never to have been acquired.

The records agree that Captain Hays served on the Staff of General Pleasanton from October 1863 until July 1864. A well published Brady view of Hays sporting a luxuriant mustache in the company of Pleasanton and with other staff members illustrates that Hays deliberately stood out. The captain’s uniform coat sports non-regulation sleeve braiding with a large shield badge. He wears the mother of all slough hats, a Texas-style wide brimmed slouch hat with fashionable upturned sides featuring a target-sized oval embroidered crossed sabers insignia. The Official Records prove that Pleasanton thought very highly of Captain Hays when the general later wrote to the Secretary of War: “A very gallant and deserving gentlemen, who served throughout the late rebellion in the regular army and has since resigned; was so distinguished for his zeal, ability and great gallantry that I beg respectfully to recommend his case for the following brevets…” The Dictionary of American Biography further asserts that Hays was awarded “gallantry” brevets for the Peninsula Campaign, Antietam, and Gettysburg, adding that General McClellan had previously recommended that he be brevetted for “gallantry” at Williamsburg. Not one of these brevets are confirmed in Heitman or the Military Record.

Nothing in the short file of post-war paperwork that accompanies his resignation letter supports the multitude of battlefield claims and brevets excepting one endorsed by General Pleasanton, and never acted upon. While on Pleasanton staff Captain Hays served intermittently as ordinance officer and provost-marshal “and commissary of musters of the cavalry corps.” The enigmatic Hays obtained a surgeon’s certificate of disability and formally resigned from the Army on July 4, 1864. His biography, written when he had attained significant wealth and influence, also makes a number of post-war claims regarding subsequent military service as “inspector of Pennsylvania State troops…with the rank of lieutenant colonel” and afterwards into 1876 as “inspector general, department of Pennsylvania” as colonel. None can be verified with the records at hand.

With the opening era of post-war industry driven by westward expansion—railroads and factories powered by coal—Henry Blake Hay’s was poised to achieve infinitely more success in civilian life. He soon became Owner-President of the H.B. Hays and Brothers Coal Railroad engaged in mining and shipping, and as a director of the Pittsburgh, Virginia and Charleston Railway, as well as several large banks—collectively netting Hays fortune and influence in the early days the "gilded age."

Hays married in the daughter of the former Mayor of Pittsburgh in 1869 and built a baronial county home that he named “Sutherland Hall.” He became a member of the prestigious MOLLUS organization, but his association with the GAR is only presumed. He died a few days short of his 52nd birthday on August 10, 1881 and was laid to rest in Allegheny Cemetery (Section 19, Lot 100), Pittsburgh. His widow, Mary Howard Hays, lived until 1921 and a surviving daughter until 1939.

There are three lots (9, 10, 11) of Henry Blake Hays' uniforms, all from the same source. A handwritten letter of provenance relating specifically to Lot 9., the Captain’s frock coat, accompanies the group.

T.Haas to Consignor 2007

Vest is best example of its kind we have ever seen.  CDV VG+. with very minor soiling.
Sold: $1,762.50
Price includes
Buyer's Premium
      Ask a Question

All Images

CDV of Gen. Geo. A. Custer
Lot # 76 - CDV of Gen. Geo. A. Custer
CDV of Custer as Brig. Gen. by Brady, taken "on or about February 15, 1864" (Katz). Pencil identification beneath portrait. Illustrated in Katz' Custer in Photographs [K-29].  > Item Details
Autographed CDV of Gen. Henry B. Carrington
Lot # 60 - Autographed CDV of Gen. Henry B. Carrington
Carte of General Henry B. Carrington ink signed beneath portrait, with G.W. Apple, Indianapolis, IN backmark. Controversial Brigadier who gained notoriety for his culpability in the 1866 Fetterman Massacre near Ft. Phil Kearny. > Item Details
Indian Wars Scabbards for Hospital Corps Knives and a Trowel Bayonet
Lot # 1229 - Indian Wars Scabbards for Hospital Corps Knives and a Trowel Bayonet
Model 1887 Hospital Corps knife first and second pattern black leather scabbards with brass fittings. Also includes a scarce Model 1869 trowel bayonet black leather scabbard, well-marked with brass tip.  > Item Details
*Walther Model PK380 Semi-Auto Pistol
Lot # 1389 - *Walther Model PK380 Semi-Auto Pistol
.380 ACP caliber, 3.5" barrel, S/N PK031262. Original box and papers. > Item Details
Pattern 1860 Field Staff Officer's Sword, Presented to Capt. Geo. B. Stadden
Lot # 1251 - Pattern 1860 Field Staff Officer's Sword, Presented to Capt. Geo. B. Stadden
30" blade with etched panels of military motifs. Nickel-plated with presentation plaque reading Presented To Capt Gerg Stadden April 8, 1887 Members of J.L. Crave Camp No 4 Ill Div SV.  Shagreen and brass wire wrapped handle; chased guard and pommel. > Item Details
**DWM Commercial Luger Imported by A.F. Stoeger
Lot # 975 - **DWM Commercial Luger Imported by A.F. Stoeger
7.63 Luger caliber, 4" barrel, S/N 7747t. Blue finish, walnut checkered grips. > Item Details
**Belgian Browning Superposed Diana Grade Over/Under Shotgun Signed by R. Dewil
Lot # 1056 - **Belgian Browning Superposed Diana Grade Over/Under Shotgun Signed by R. Dewil
12 ga., 30" barrels choked F/M, S/N 80904. blue barrels, coin finished engraved receiver signed by R. Dewil. High grade walnut checkered stocks. LOP 14.375" over original Browning pad. 1960 date of mfg., ivory mid- and front beads, single trigger. > Item Details
Custom Fixed-Blade Stilletto by <i>Tommy Lee</i>
Lot # 1750 - Custom Fixed-Blade Stilletto by Tommy Lee
11" o.a.l., 6.625" Damascus blade. Engraved hilt, ivory handles with gold wire inlay. Leather sheath. > Item Details
Custom Knife by <i>Lora Sue Bethke</i>
Lot # 1777 - Custom Knife by Lora Sue Bethke
5.5" blade, marked on along the top edge Lora Sue Bethke, and on the reverse JS.  Brass guard; aluminum, red acrylic, leather and stag used in the handle. Handle is similar to a Scagel.  Blade is nicely polished. > Item Details
Victorian Copy of a Spanish Swept-Hilt Sword
Lot # 1352 - Victorian Copy of a Spanish Swept-Hilt Sword
Late 19th century copy with a 32" blade. Maker marked Ernst Schmidt. > Item Details
Winchester Model 1887 Lever-Action Shotgun
Remington Model 1889 Grade 1 Side-by-Side Double-Barrel Hammer Shotgun
Lot # 1593 - Remington Model 1889 Grade 1 Side-by-Side Double-Barrel Hammer Shotgun
12 ga., 30" Damascus barrels choked M/IM, S/N 14743. Case colored receiver, walnut checkered stocks. > Item Details
Five CDVs: Kilpatrick, Randolph B. Marcy, Giliman Marston, John Martindale, John S. Mason
Lot # 143 - Five CDVs: Kilpatrick, Randolph B. Marcy, Giliman Marston, John Martindale, John S. Mason
Lot of 5: Brady view of Bvt. Maj. Gen. Randolph B. Marcy '28; consummate staff officer awarded two brevets. Brady carte of Brig. Gen. Gilman Marston, Col. 2nd NH; departmental commander, later assigned to Point Lookout prison, returned to field in charge of a brigade during the Ov... > Item Details
**Side-by-Side Double-Barrel Shotguns, Lot of Three
Lot # 1652 - **Side-by-Side Double-Barrel Shotguns, Lot of Three
1) Riverside Arms, 20 ga., 28" barrels, S/N 44546.  Very good condition with very good bores. 2) Empire Arms Model 60, 12 ga., 28" barrels, S/N 33147. Good to very good condition with very good bores. 3) Lefever Nitro Special, 12 ga., 30" barrels, S/N 207256.... > Item Details
Civil War Officer's Private Purchase Sack Coat Identified as Lt. Col. Peter Osterhaus, 12th Missouri Volunteers
Lot # 4 - Civil War Officer's Private Purchase Sack Coat Identified as Lt. Col. Peter Osterhaus, 12th Missouri Volunteers
Dark wool body double-breasted 4-button coat with notched lapels. Buttons do not have any maker's marks.  Buttons have an "I" on the shield of the eagle's breast.  Major's oak leaves with prongs that stick through the shoulder and folded it over.  Dark olive lini... > Item Details
*Keltec P3AT Semi-Auto Pistol
Lot # 1493 - *Keltec P3AT Semi-Auto Pistol
.380 ACP caliber, 2.625" barrel, S/N KR642. Original box and papers. > Item Details
**Remington Model 1894 CE Grade Side-by-Side Double-Barrel Shotgun
Lot # 1618 - **Remington Model 1894 CE Grade Side-by-Side Double-Barrel Shotgun
12 ga., 28" Damascus barrels choked IC/M, S/N P110555. Checkered walnut stocks, DT, extractors. > Item Details
Model 1861 Special Rifled-Musket
Lot # 850 - Model 1861 Special Rifled-Musket
.58 caliber,  40" round barrel. Dated 1863 on the top flat near breech; V P and eagle on the left flat at breech. Three-leaf rear barrel sight. Eagle on the bolster, lockplate marked US LG NY Windsor and dated 1863. Three barrel bands. Walnut stock. > Item Details
Kentucky Percussion Rifle by Renton
Lot # 815 - Kentucky Percussion Rifle by Renton
.40 caliber, 44.5" octagonal barrel. Forward action percussion lock engraved and marked Renton in a diamond.  Brass furniture and two-piece brass patchbox.  Double-set triggers; maple stock. > Item Details
ITEMS 1-20 of 20